This book awesome, it started really interested. In the middle it got pretty dry, but the ending was very action pack. I’m excited to watch the series when the Library gets it.
Having just watched season 1 of the tv series, I wanted to re-visit this great book that I read years ago. It still holds up as a fantastic example of Gaiman's work, and as a fantastic piece of uniquely-American folklore.
I enjoyed the book. It meandered a bit but given that most of the story took place on the road, it fit well. There were many colourful and unique characters and the reader was left to interpret them by their actions rather than their thoughts. The plot had many jogs, turns, and spins and Gaiman's storytelling was very compelling. I found myself trying to anticipate where the story was going. I was sometimes satisfied by my correct guesses and sometimes by the unanticipated direction the story took. I enjoyed feeling sympathetic towards flawed characters made more interesting by their bizarre circumstances. Recommended for those who like magic realism, mythology, semiotics, and the dark and strange.
American Gods fell far below my expectations given the hype surrounding it. Gaiman struggles to figure out how to introduce a female character in a way that doesn't remark on her beauty and curvaceous form (or lack thereof) save for a scant few characters. The book feels way too bulky for what it is as well. It meanders to the point where, by the time I hit the halfway mark, I was just bored silly. The premise is interesting and has potential but I was mostly just unimpressed. If you can overlook the sexism and long-winded plot I'm sure it's enjoyable, but I just couldn't get myself to pick it back up.
A Masterpiece, this is Neil Gaiman at his best.
The deluxe audio book is also utterly fantastic.
I finished this book, and felt like I had missed something. So many people recommended this book to me, and I just didn’t get it. I felt like Gaiman just wanted to cleverly introduce various gods and goddesses without the storyline necessarily going anywhere. And at the end of the book, I felt like I still didn’t know Shadow at all. Maybe I should have read the original instead of the tenth anniversary edition and saved myself 12,000 words.
The show is based on Gaiman's 2001 book, which follows Shadow, a man who returns to his hometown to find that the love of his life and best friend are dead. He is then left to put together the pieces. The first episode is set to premiere at the SXSW’s annual film festival on Starz network.
I read critics comments on the book and put myself on the waiting list. I enjoyed it. Not my absolute favourite of speculative fiction. But Shadow is an interesting anti-hero and the gods in their various disguises - or incarnations - are weird and funny. So I picked up "The Ocean at the End of the Lane" which is foreshadowed in American Gods - or vice versa - and am enjoying that as well.
I picked this up because I love Neil Gaiman and the premise intrigued me. I have mixed feelings about this because I love the concept and struggled a bit with the execution. I'm really curious to see how this translates to TV...and looking forward to reading the sequel. I really enjoyed listening to this one!
I had a really tough time with this one. I went in kind of blind. I knew very little of the plot beyond the synopsis and just jumped on the book because I wanted to read it before the show started. I’ve had this on my to-read list for ages and moved it up, way up, when I heard Ian McShane was in the show! Love that guy.
Anyways, I has the version with the author’s commentary in the beginning. He mentioned that it would be a meandering journey. And boy did he mean that. I struggled through this. It was slow and dull in so many parts that I nearly put it down about a dozen times. I get building atmospheric settings, etc. but I don’t need a soliloquy describing every weather pattern that occurs throughout America. It ended up being a slog from start to finish for me. And while I normally love anything to do with mythology this just didn’t do it for me.
For me, a lot of my issues with this book came down to a lack of coherence. There were entire passages, entire chapters, that didn’t make a lick of sense to me. I get the overall gist of the plot and the character arcs but there were points throughout this text where I was well and truly lost. I feel that those areas could have been made clearer for the reader, just from a writing standpoint. I also feel that some of the characters were barely sketched out. Many of the gods were only explored on a surface level which does not allow me to form a clear picture or grow attached. Then these characters vanished, not to be mentioned for quite some time until they were needed again for whatever reason and brought back, usually in a flow breaking manner. The pacing was disrupted continually like this. I liked the coming to America breaks. Those were clearly stated and allowed for a depth to the plot but the random asides that just popped up were disorienting.
I feel so conflicted about this award winning novel by the legendary Neil Gaiman. Just so nobody comes to my house brandishing torches and pitchforks, I want to state for the record that I do enjoy Gaiman's comics, but this book left me with mixed emotions. Characters, especially some of the more interesting gods like Easter and Media, are barely present, Shadow (the protagonist) is a tough character to root for, and the book has some slower parts that are difficult to get through resulting in me wanting to skip some passages. Although I love his worldbuilding, dialogue, and writing style, American Gods left me unsatisfied in its execution and didn't deliver 100% on such an intriguing premise. I'm excited to see Bryan Fuller's take on American Gods when the show premieres later this month on Starz, as I feel he will fix some of my major criticisms of the book when adaptating it. Overall, there are many sections of American Gods that I love, but as a whole, the book played out like a series of loosely connected short stories that left me wanting more. I think that had I been in the mood for a slower paced book, this would have been a 5 star read.
A Sunday afternoon drive of a read. While it is a nice slow burn throughout, you never feel as if it's not worth your time or not engaging. Extremely enjoyable!
A great, page-turning read this is as much about America (the geography, the personality and history of the place) as it is about myths and gods and magic. Gaiman takes us on a journey and it's an enjoyable ride.
From suspense to mystery, a love story and dark character development to fantasy and mythology this book has a bit of everything. Neil Gaiman cleverly weaves old world mythology into this fantastical modern day fable. As someone who enjoys fairy tales and following mythology I really enjoyed figuring out who the characters were based on from Gaiman's subtle interpretations. This book has a lot of complexity and depth too it and yet I felt it read easily and was an interesting story to follow.
I'm still not sure how I feel about this one. In Gaiman's introduction to the 10th anniversary edition he notes that a lot of readers either love or hate the book but I don't fall into either of those camps. The concept is interesting and clever and some of the characters are fascinating but the book lacks that certain je ne sais quoi that makes me love so many of Gaiman's other books and tales. If you're a fan of mythology and Gaiman this is a definite must-read, otherwise I say give it a try and find out where you fall on the spectrum.
An engrossing tale with a fun, dark mash-up of various mythologies. Neil Gaiman can certainly tell a story, and bonus points for me not seeing most of the plot twists coming. Knocked down a star because by the end of the book I was left wondering: so what?
This reminded me of an American folk story of the tall tales ilk where the protagonist is a sort of easy-going, self-effacing everyman aptly named “Shadow” who’s on a supernatural road trip in the American mid-west. I found nothing profound about the pagan gods of the old world battling it out with the new gods of modernity; Gaiman studiously avoids any mention of serious, main stream religions with one god (Christianity, Judaism, Islam) probably to avoid giving offense. In the introduction Gaiman, a Brit just transplanted to the US, states that he was trying to capture the feel of America through its small towns, bizarre roadside attractions, and automobile centricity. This version is the original and expanded text; I can see why it was edited. An interesting read, but not a compelling one.
Gaiman presents a book part mystery, part travelogue, and big part fantasy in this sprawling novel. It's an interesting meditation on mythology and belief tied up in a great story.
I find this book disgusting, for all of its intellect or skillful story-telling. The idea of TV, sex, cars, etc being the new American gods is neither original nor particularly interesting as a work of fiction and definitely a downer for someone who would like a more positive outlook on the world.
I enjoyed the concept of the new American Gods competing with the Old World Gods, but there were times when I found my attention waning. It was a good book overall, but not great for me.
Gaiman turns our conception of "gods" onto its modern American head, illustrating how values have changed, and where our new altars lie. Using the road trip as his vehicle, past and present forces clash when an unwitting recently released convict becomes the chauffer, or bagman, for some new American Gods.
Not the best of fantasy books, I have read. There is a sense of mystery in teh story. But not awesome enough to give a 5 star. The story is definitely a page turner, but the revelation not so thunderous.
The story is about the gods in the American continents and a war between them and the story of a man named shadow caught in the middle. Who is he, why is he important, why the war and what is the meaning of all this. These mysteries are definitely worth a read.
I Liked it but I enjoyed some of his other projects better. It dragged sometimes for me.
By far Neil's best book. The characters are relateable and interesting, the plot line is enjoyable and Shadow is a enjoyable character to follow around.
An incredibly witty and intelligent tale in which Gaiman weave together mythological figures from different worlds.