I don't know how this book won a Pulitzer Prize. I thought it was WAY too long and ponderous and the back and forth between story lines and time frames did not contribute to the story. By the final third I was itching for the book to end and put me and the characters out of their misery. And it doesn't really end, it just kind of dribbles away. It also suffers from the
Forest Gump effect of creating a character with a physical disability who is extraordinary in all other ways -- extra smart, extra caring, extra brave. Disappointing.
Amazing synopsis, intriguing cover, anticlimactic and slow story. I had to force myself to read this book after the first 200 pages (out of 531!). It took me 2 months to finish and my favorite character was killed off. Isn't that great?
The rising action/main story was very very VERY slow and was anticlimactic (pretty much 80% of the book). There were a lot of unnecessary chapters and segments that were repetitive of the last. I will admit that All the Light We Cannot See had good falling action (10% of the book) since it was super emotional. It was also the point where the story ties a clean knot between the character development and plot. I felt like the book would be better if the end of the book was the falling action instead of the character epilogue (the last 10%). All the Light We Cannot See is more of a character study, like Six of Crows, if you have read that.
Beautiful writing and compelling story. The very end, which updated the story in vignettes from 1974 and 2014, felt jarring compared to the lyrical prose of the WWII section.
I loved the way this book brought on an entirely new perspective to WW2, with the use of a 2 perspective narrative Dorr was able to perfectly capture the ignorance of both the germans and those under rule of Germany. I would recommend this book to anyone looking for an intelligent and meaningful read.
On of those books you hear so much praise for you think it can't live up to the hype. For me, it did and more. Doerr blends science and art, poetry and prose, untrammeled beauty and the horror of war into a riveting book that serves up its short chapters like confections. I found myself late at night saying, "Well, just one more."
Marie-Laure is the solid grounded center around which the book revolves and her blindness doesn't make her a cipher or unnaturally noble--she's a real kid who simply deals with her lot in life and tries to survive and take what joys she can. At the same time, her tenous situation is made all the more dangerous by being caught in a war zone being fought over by the Allies and Axis. There are some rich poetic moments and some grisly ones--the author doesn't hold back. In a book where hiding is integral to the story, nothing is hidden from the reader.
It was just okay...definitely had some inventive high points but it didn't quite hold me...I wanted to really love it...
A lovely book that subtly focusses on the goodness - the light - inside some people in the face of horror and evil. Well worth a read, but only four stars because I thought going into the future at the end of the story was a mistake.
War is hell. But this novel is at the top with my all time favourite books. Beautifully written, with unforgettable characters and a plot that draws you in and doesn't let go. It was even better on the second reading.
Anthony Doerr’s All The Light We Cannot See is an absolutely amazing piece of literature! It is a novel of realistic and historical fiction, and revolves around the two main characters Marie-Laure LeBlanc who is a blind Parisian, and Werner Pfennig who is a German orphan. The novel propels the readers through the characters’ life stories during the Nazi invasion in 1944. Anthony Doerr is an incredibly intelligible man who brings out the world of science and history in poetic forms so that it is communicable to readers of all ages and interest. I loved this book and the way every setting, person, or event was described with such a vast lexicon that brought the supposed mood to the readers. Hats off to Anthony Doerr and All The Light We Cannot See! I definitely give this book a 5/5 star rating! I recommend this book for ages 12 and up!
- @ilovefood of The Hamilton Public Library's Teen Review Board
As deep as the ocean and more, this book will pull in readers with its unresistable hypotonizing charm. Marie-Laure, the purest soul one could ever meet, is a genuine protagonist to follow. Werner, a bright young man who would rather be defined by his thoughts than his intelligence, goes through things that would break down almost anyone else. Although I was expecting the two to meet up, it didn't happen until way past halfway in the book. I didn't know what I was supposed to be expecting, but this was clearly not a romance book. Metaphorically, they both lived through a cloudy and dark day. I think their only meeting was like a moment of light, like a bright red of a sunset that escaped the veil, before the setting of the sun into the water. 4/5 stars
- @Siri of the Teen Review Board of the Hamilton Public Library
This story is a combination of two tales; that of Marie-Laure, and that of Werner. Both are on conflicting sides in the middle of one of the largest wars on earth; world war 2. But throughout the story, you see how similar these people are, and how, in light of these recent events, people still retain their humanity. A quote that I found touched me the most, and that summarizes the story exquisitely, is this, "'Your problem Werner,' says Frederick (Werner's friend from cadets), 'is that you still believe you own your life.'" This is true for both Werner and Marie-Laure. For, amongst the ashes, we will rise. Hope, innocence, and loyalty is all tested in this one, tremendous story of hearts that will never break. I would recommend this to anyone who has ever felt anything at all in their hearts. Be prepared for a worthwhile week on the couch with the Kleenex box.
- @AelinBaggins of the Teen Review Board of the Hamilton Public Library
I was mesmerized by the pair of plots to read on to discover how the German and French characters would meet - and the consequences. Unfortunately, I felt disappointed as the various plot lines seemed to evaporate toward the end of the book. Also, some technical details were annoyingly wrong such as repeated use of the words "anti-air battery" (anti-aircraft battery), "razor wire" (barbed wire), and "jumpsuit" (overalls). The author provides a chilling portrayal of youth indoctrination to fascist gang mentality which resonates with current events.
I enjoyed this book but I was not blown away by it. I love the 2 separate stories, and the language is so vivid. It's definitely one of those books you can lose yourself in.
Very eloquently written, but it was just too slow for me. I couldn't make it past the halfway point, I just didn't feel invested in the characters. I wasn't motivated to keep reading. Just wasn't for me I guess!
LOVED this book. So beautifully written and Doerr did an excellent job of weaving different characters' stories together. Also interesting to see how he 'ended' the characters' stories. The beginning was a bit slow, so make sure you power through it.
It’s not often that I read an absorbing page-turner of *literary* quality and I loved this one. Although it’s yet another novel set during WW2, it is full of intricate invention, yet well researched, and full of humanity – the horror and wonder, the lies and the love. The attention to detail is outstanding. Doerr’s format of flipping frequently back and forth between the two main protagonists makes for easy reading, but flipping back and forth in time did not add any value to the novel for me …and at times confusion toward the end. Nevertheless, a memorable, worthwhile read.
I enjoyed this book immensely and was very impressed with the love exhibited by the father in crafting the model of the neighborhood and then the city for his daughter. There was not a great deal of info or detail about the war and its misery and terror but apparently that was not the subject that Doerr wanted to explore. Anyway, I recommend this book to adult readers.
This is one of the best novels I've read in a long time. The characters are very well developed, wartime circumstances difficult and choices each character needs to make are difficult. A very nice balance between an intricate plot and wonderful character development. Great for a book club
A beautiful story of a blind French girl and German boy during World War II, what they must do trying to survive and how their lives connect. This is a book to savor.
While on the lengthy side, the short chapters and compelling characters make this a page-turner. Though the ending fell into place a little too easily for me, this novel otherwise lives up to the hype.
"All the Light We Cannot See" by Anthony Doerr held my attention all the way through maybe because like Werner I was a bit of a radio fanatic as a kid. And, I loved St Malo as a setting. Great read!
This book moved a little slow for me, especially at first, but I found that the more I read it, the more enjoyable it became. I felt invested in the characters and desperately wanted to find out what happens to them. The story-line is nonlinear, the characters are complex and the tone is reflective. The book is also richly detailed and slightly suspenseful.
I loved this book and highly recommend it! The story weaves together characters and themes thoughtfully and artfully. This is one I couldn't put down.